In Germany, the court for the first time allowed the extradition of a Ukrainian who refused to serve in the Armed Forces: what is known

For the first time, Germany has approved the extradition of a Ukrainian who refused military service. Find out what are the circumstances of the case, the court's decision and its implications for future extradition proceedings
In Germany, the Federal Supreme Court for the first time approved the extradition of a Ukrainian citizen who tried to avoid returning by claiming conscientious objection. The man explained his position by saying that he did not want to participate in the armed conflict and kill people.
Circumstances of the case
Ukrainian law enforcement agencies filed a request for extradition of a citizen who, according to them, had threatened and physically abused a police officer. When Germany initiated the extradition procedure, the man opposed his return to Ukraine, arguing that he could be forced to serve in the army contrary to his beliefs.
Request to the Federal Supreme Court
As the case sparked legal debate, the Dresden Higher Land Court asked the German Federal Supreme Court for clarification. The main question was whether the extradition request of the Ukrainian side could be granted in this case.
Don't want to miss important updates and useful articles? Subscribe to our weekly newsletter!
Court decision and its consequences
The German Federal Supreme Court ruled that conscientious objection is not a sufficient ground to prevent extradition. The court noted that if the state is attacked in violation of international law, the relevant persons may be called up for military service.
In addition, the court's decision states that the right to refuse military service is not absolute. The German Basic Law and the European Convention on Human Rights do not contain any provisions that would prevent extradition in this case.
The court decision may become a precedent for other similar cases in the future. It emphasizes that avoiding military service does not guarantee protection from extradition if there are other legal grounds for extradition. It also shows that international law and domestic German law do not always consider objections to military service as an unconditional reason for granting asylum or refusing to extradite a person to another state.
The case of the Ukrainian, whom Germany agreed to extradite, can be seen as an important precedent in European legal practice. It demonstrates that refusal to serve in the military is not always a sufficient argument to avoid extradition, especially if the country of origin requires the person to be returned due to criminal charges. This decision may have an impact on future similar cases and define new approaches to extradition in Europe.
Situations related to extradition and conscientious objection can have complex legal consequences. To avoid mistakes and know your rights, it is important to get qualified legal assistance. Our experts will analyze your case and help you build the right defense strategy.
📩 Contact us for professional support - your safety and rights are above all!
We remind you! Ukrainian refugees have started to leave three European countries - Denmark, Italy and France. We told you why this trend is happening and in which countries, on the contrary, the number of Ukrainians is growing.
Want to know more? Read the latest news and useful materials about Ukraine and the world in the News section.
We recommend purchasing it for a safe and comfortable trip to Ukraine:
Visit Ukraine Insurance – insurance covering military risks for entry and travel in Ukraine;
Visit Ukraine Car Insurance – car insurance with extended coverage in Ukraine;
Visit Ukraine Legal Advice – comprehensive legal support on entry to Ukraine;
Visit Ukraine Tickets – bus and train tickets to/from Ukraine;
Visit Ukraine Tours – the largest online database of tours to Ukraine for every taste;
Visit Ukraine Hotels – hotels for a comfortable stay in Ukraine;
Visit Ukraine Merch – patriotic clothing and accessories with worldwide delivery.
© 2018-2025, Visit Ukraine. Use, copying or reprinting of materials on this site is permitted only with a link (hyperlink for online publications) to Visit Ukraine.
All rights reserved.
Recommended articles
2 min
Insurance
War risk insurance in Ukraine: maximum protection against unforeseen situations
Responsible attitude and reliable protection are the key to a safe stay in Ukraine. Find out what are the benefits of insurance covering active and passive war risks, as well as its prices, validity period and amount of insurance coverage.
17 Feb. 2025
More details3 min
Transport
Technical inspection 2025: which cars should be inspected, cost and other important changes
In Ukraine, certain categories of drivers are required to undergo regular vehicle inspections. This is due to the need to bring Ukrainian legislation in line with the requirements of the European Union. Find out more about which cars are subject to inspection, what the cost of maintenance will be, and what other changes are expected
17 Feb. 2025
More details2 min
Where to go?
Wonders of Zakarpattia and Lumshory: go on a magical journey with Visit Ukraine
We invite you to discover the magical land of Zakarpattia, where unique experiences and unforgettable adventures await you. From the medieval fortress of Tustan to the healing thermal waters of Kosyno, from authentic Lumshory vats to exquisite cheese tasting - every day of your trip will be filled with new discoveries. Find out more about your unforgettable trip with Visit Ukraine
17 Feb. 2025
More details1 min
Documents
Ukraine resumes issuing passports to men abroad: how to get a document?
The issuance of passports to men abroad has resumed. Find out who can get a document, what requirements need to be met and how the issuance process will work
17 Feb. 2025
More details